Wednesday, July 8, 2020

Albertina Kerr Nursery


The sadness here is not about the loss of a fine old building.  The building will survive.  The sadness is about loss of its pleasant and memorable public uses – no thanks to COVID-19.

There will be no more gourmet lunches or teas at Albertina’s Kitchen, at 424 N.E. 22nd Ave., nor any more sales at Albertina's Heirlooms, one of Portland's finest shops for antique glass, china, jewelry, knickknacks and small furnishings.

 After nearly 40 years of engaging directly with members of the public, the stylish 1921 Colonial Revival Albertina Kerr Center will continue being the administrative headquarters of a non-profit that provides services at several locations to children with mental health issues and adults with intellectual or developmental disabilities.

“After thoughtful consideration it is with heavy heart that we have made the difficult decision to permanently close the restaurant and shops at Albertina’s Place,” Jeff Carr, Kerr’s CEO, posted on the agency’s website.  Albertina's Closet, a thrift shop, operated from a separate building on the same property. He said the pandemic led to too much concern for health safety with the public uses.  

The closures do not weigh heavily on Kerr’s bottom line.  The mostly-volunteer-run shops and restaurant netted about $450,000 last year, a pittance in a total agency budget of more than $43 million.

However, the closures will weigh on the many people who enjoyed stylish, leisurely and tasty lunches, and slow ambles through the antiques for sale.  Kerr had a staff of volunteer antiques experts who weighed the merit and value of all items brought in as proposed consignments; they rejected items they concluded were unworthy of the inventory.

On the plus side, closure of the public commerce will not affect the maintenance of the building, which has been well-maintained by Kerr given its 99-year history.  The Albertina Kerr Nursery was built in honor of Albertina Kerr, who died one year after her marriage to Alexander Kerr in 1910.  Mrs. Kerr had a strong commitment to newborn babies who needed help, and the family home in Northwest provided adoption services and daycare for single mothers after her death. 

 Alexander Kerr,  a deeply religious man who was founder of the Kerr Glass Jar Co., carried on with his wife's charitable enthusiasm. Kerr managed his successful business from Portland, but the glass canning jars were produced in San Francisco and in the Midwest. 

Those nursery operations expanded in 1921 with completion of the new Albertina Kerr Nursery, designed by the architecture firm headed by Folger Johnson.  Johnson, who arrived in Portland in 1911, had some of the fanciest training among local architects of his era, with a degree from Columbia University and having studied at the Ecole des Beaux Arts in Paris, then the world’s leading school for classical architecture studies.

 

Johnson chose a Colonial Revival theme (called Georgian for King George III in England, but Americans  rebelled against King George so we call it "colonial"), which is noted for its red brick walls and classical ornaments such as the Corinthian columns at the front entry and the pediment above.  Johnson included a round window, called an oculus, in the pediment.  It was a technique he had used elsewhere, also.

 In a light-hearted twist to classical design, the Kerr façade includes medallions composed of infants in swaddling clothes above the windows.  The nursery was used for babies awaiting adoptions from its opening until 1967.

 

Johnson’s work survives in several categories.  He did some elegant homes in exclusive neighborhoods, and four small libraries in Multnomah County funded by Andrew Carnegie.  The St. John’s branch remains as a library, while three others have different uses, including the history museum in Gresham.

 Johnson served as a consultant on Benson High School.  His most elegant building likely is The Portland Town Club, a private club for women erected in 1928 at 2115 S.W. Salmon.  You can see the outside of it here:

https://www.thetownclub.org/

 Like many architects of his era, Johnson's’ commissions plummeted during the Depression, which prevented him from adding to an inventory of elegant architecture.  He spent a decade starting in 1940 as Oregon director of the Federal Housing Administration.

 Johnson and his wife were active participants in Portland’s social life, and he frequently spoke to groups about architecture and gardens.  He never forgot his association with the Kerr building.  At his death at age 88 in 1970, his family recommended memorial donations to Albertina Kerr Nursery. 

Some volunteers who worked at the restaurant and heirloom shop hope that those services eventually will return.  It may well be that positive associations with those enterprises helped create awareness and fundraising possibilities for the agency's charitable work. 

UPDATE ON NEW CHINATOWN-JAPANTOWN HEIGHT ALLOWANCES

Much to no one's surprise, the Portland City Council on June 2 voted 3 to 1 to set building height allowances of 200 feet in the New Chinatown Japantown Historic District in Northwest Portland.

As you can read in an earlier blog post, preservation advocates urged a 125-foot maximum in the neighborhood where most buildings are generally not more than three or four stories.  The 200-foot maximum would allow buildings of close to 20 stories.

As a consequence of the building heights, owners of the small buildings essentially are encouraged to let them run down so they can be demolished.  Kristen Minor, chair of the Portland Historical Landmarks Commission, had urged heights of no more than 100 to 125 feet.  "It's disappointing there was no effort to compromise," said Commissioner Amanda Fritz, who cast the dissenting vote.  Fritz was disappointed that the council wasn't influenced by Minor's testimony. 

A crush of new buildings likely is not going to occur quickly, given economic circumstances.  But eventually it will come.  If the historic district is to have any relevance in the years ahead, it may well be only in photographs and historic displays in tower lobbies.   




Friday, June 26, 2020

"God is in the details"



The quotation above, surely one of the greatest in architectural lore, came from a mid-20th Century master of the glass and steel skyscraper, Ludwig Mies van der Rohe.  Of course, its meaning is not limited to the modern era.

Nobody in Portland has a better sense of late 19th-Century classical details than architect William J. Hawkins III, who has devoted a long career to architectural research, writing and design.  When the 1888 Morris Marks house, above, was moved to its new location after a prolonged struggle over siting and transportation, Hawkins knew that the classic Italianate house was missing some elegant details in its elaborate wooden facade.

Before the move, this long-neglected stick-built house was close to becoming a pile of kindling.  The time-lapse video below illustrates how the building was sliced into two pieces in order to be  removed from the original site on S.W. 12th Ave.  The move was complicated by the presence of MAX and streetcar wires that limited route options, and by a pedestrian overpass that thwarted a move down S.W. Broadway.


Here's a still image of the house early on the morning it was moved:




The new owners, Karen Karlsson and Rick Michaelson, engaged in heroic efforts to move the building and plan its restoration.  The move and most of the renovation work was undertaken by Arciform, a Portland design-build firm willing to tackle the most difficult preservation/restoration projects.

However, the restoration budget didn't allow for replacement and Corinthian capitals missing from the front porch, and for a new balustrades for the front porch.   

"I just couldn't bear to have those columns unrestored," Hawkins said.  How to pay for it?  He and Dave Talbot, a specialist in replicating historical architectural details decided to call on their lists of preservation advocates to make contributions.  The request netted $17,300, enough to get the work done.

Meanwhile Hawkins needed to figure out what the long-gone capitals looked like.  "They were a stock item in the 1880s," he said.  "You could buy decorated capitals and attach them to columns if you could afford it."  Hawkins also studied the capitals adorning pilasters near the front door, and figured how to take those "flat" details into round capitals.  The new capitals are made from cast aluminum.




The capitals and balustrade are Hawkins' only contribution to the renovation.  "They allowed me to be totally independent," he said of the owners.  "I didn't want to be intrusive.  They were very nice about it."

Given its siting on a triangular piece of ground at 2177 S.W. Broadway, the original front entrance is closed off and porch becomes perhaps Portland's most elegant deck.  Entry to the building will be from the side.  The building will be leased for offices.

The Italianate house was one of many designed by Warren H. Williams, one of Portland's most notable architects in the late 19th Century.  This was the first of two houses he designed for a successful shoe merchant, Morris Marks.  "Williams probably did hundreds of handsome houses," Hawkins said, "but now we are down to just a handful."

This is the second Williams building that has found life after what appeared to be likely death.  Back in the 1960s, early in Bill Hawkins' career, preservation enthusiasts rallied to save Williams' pioneer gothic Calvary Presbyterian Church, which we know today at the Old Church. "Fortunately, we didn't have to move the Old Church," Hawkins said.

Sadly, perhaps, most people will see this new restoration  only as they drive past, since parking is not easy on the triangle of land where it sits.  But as Dave Talbot suggested, once traffic returns to normal, people will have time to admire it while stuck in traffic jams. 

Hawkins laughed when he was reminded of the Miesian quotation in the headline of this article.  He then suggested a minor alteration: "God is in the elegant details."













Tuesday, June 23, 2020

History Repeats!




Nothing better can happen to a well-maintained, gracious historic building than returning to its original use.

We should stage a huge celebration, then, for reopening of the Albina Branch of the Multnomah County Library, scheduled to occur on July 1.  This magnificent Spanish-Renaissance style building with stucco walls and red tile roof at 216 N.E. Knott St. served as the Albina branch from its completion in 1912 until 1960, when library officials felt it necessary to move to a more densely-populated neighborhood.

Most recently, the 1912 building has served as the Title Wave Bookstore where the library sells unneeded or donated books.  Unlike many public buildings, this one has been nicely maintained, right down to its original interior oak woodwork and decorative plaster ceiling ornaments. Perhaps the hiatus from “active service” saved it from the egregious attempts at remodeling that afflict so many public buildings.
 
"Timely"  interior design

(We must take exception to the boringly pedestrian fluorescent lighting tubes that replaced the original fixtures  That is a relatively cheap “fix” should someone be so inspired.)

The history of the building is just as interesting as its timeless architecture.  The branch was the second of seven in Multnomah County funded by grants from Andrew Carnegie between 1911 and 1922.  Carnegie’s deal was that he would pay for construction of free public libraries if the recipients provided the land, books and staffing.

Carnegie declined to help pay for the Main Library downtown.  He wanted his libraries in neighborhoods, where young people could improve their lives by free access to information, and where immigrants could learn English and how to manage life in America. (Carnegie's family had come from Scotland when he was a teenager.)  In all, he built some 1400 libraries in the United States.  Some communities rejected his offer, based largely on a 1892 Homestead strike-breaking effort that led to 10 fatalities near the Pittsburgh steel mill. 
 
The original reading room (Multnomah County Library photo)

The unschooled Carnegie had built his fortune in the steel industry, where his profits were generated by cutting costs to be a price leader and by ruthless employment practices.  By the late 1800s, he had amassed an estate hundreds of millions of dollars.  In 1889 he published “The Gospel of Wealth,” in which he said super-wealthy people should distribute their assets while they were alive to improve the public good.

Carnegie kept his word.

He knew he and his staff could not supervise all the building projects, so local architects were given the jobs.  However, Carnegie did provide suggested floor plans and two key requirements: The buildings had to have stairways to the main entrances, so visitors would feel they were being “elevated,” and there had to be prominent exterior light fixtures so visitors would feel “enlightened.”

Carnegie's donations had a major impact on the nation's library systems.  Many libraries, including Portland in the early years, were funded by subscriptions paid by library users.  Carnegie insisted that his libraries be open to the public without cost.  His libraries also pioneered the "self service" concept in which library users could make their own selections from shelves and check them out at a central desk.  This system reduced employee costs and let readers choose their own books without having to ask a librarian to select them from behind counters. 

"Elevated and enlightened" 

A young Portland architect on his way to greater prominence, Ellis F. Lawrence, designed the Albina branch.  It was one of some 500 projects he helped design during a busy career that included almost 42 years as the founder and dean of the University of Oregon’s School of Architecture and Allied Arts.  Lawrence lived in Portland and commuted to Eugene by train a few days per week until his death in 1946.

Two significant changes have occurred at the Albina branch over the years.  The library system built an addition at the rear of the building to create space for book-binding.  Carnegie's insistence on the entry stairway decades later led to the addition of an entry ramp for people with disabilities.  Neither the rear addition nor the ramp impair the original elegant architectural presence. 

Restoration of the Albina building to library use means that three of the seven Carnegie-funded buildings are still functioning as libraries.  The others are North Portland and St. Johns, both nicely restored in recent years.  Two others, East Portland and Arleta, were sold by the county and still exist but have been converted to other purposes. The Gresham library is now operated as a museum by the Gresham Historical Society and last one, South Portland, erected in 1922 well after Carnegie's death, is a neighborhood office staffed by Portland Parks and Recreation.

The county based its decision to  return to the Knott Street building in part on cost savings.  It no longer will be paying for leased space for a small branch in a shopping mall at N.E. 15th Ave. and Fremont St.  The real value, however, is returning a beautiful and historic building to a higher and better public use.


FURTHERMORE:

Time is slowly running out to comment on the Park Bureau's tentative master plan for the South Park Blocks.  If you prefer to see the blocks left uncluttered, please review this website and click on the survey box.  This is our only chance to speak out before a final plan goes tot he City 
Council.



Wednesday, June 17, 2020

Darcelle XV Showplace


Images from National Register of Historic Places nomination 


When Walter Cole gave his first drag performance in a small tavern in Old Town in 1969, the stage consisted of two tables bolted to the floor.  The “stage lighting” came from a slide projector.

Now, more than 50 years later, the Darcelle XV Showplace has expanded into a second storefront and  erected a permanent stage with spotlights.  The glitzy-cheap-wacky decorations have grown in scope, as has Cole’s assemblage of self-sewn exotic gowns stored in the basement.

 Along the way, Cole, now 89, has become a Portland icon for developing a nightclub that attracts and charms people of all sexual persuasions.  He also has been a tireless fundraiser for many charities both related and unrelated to sexual interests and difficulties.

 Through it all, Cole “advanced gay acceptance through humor rather than violence or protest,” said Brandon Spencer-Hartle, historic resources program manager for the City of Portland.  Spencer-Hartle  introduced a National Register of Historic Places nomination for Darcelle’s before the Portland Historic Landmarks Commission.

 The National Register nomination relates the importance of Cole’s social  history more than the historic value of the building at 208 N.W. Third Avenue.  It details the long history of and persecution of gay nightclubs in Portland and other cities during the 20th Century.

“As a nightclub and drag venue, the aesthetic of Darcelle XV Showplace reflects the improvised, low-budget, and self-reliant illusion of glamour that resulted from its development during this era when drag was celebrated mostly behind closed doors due to gay discrimination and the threat of harassment…

Walter Cole, 1970

 “Walter Cole, as the proprietor and star drag performer of his club starting in 1969, staked his livelihood on his ability to gain straight allies. He did more than that -- he grew into his role as a community leader even as he stood up for people many disavowed at the time, including transsexuals, performers of color, lesbians, and always, drag performers. Darcelle XV is one of only two drag clubs open prior to 1970 in the United States with an owner who also performed (and is still performing!) as part of the company, and the only one still in the same location today.”

 Cole bought what was then the Demas Tavern in 1967, after urban renewal forced him to move a jazz club from downtown Portland.  It was a tough start.  “All of our gay friends wouldn’t go across Burnside because it was in Skid Road,” Cole said.  Given that it was a neighborhood best known for single men and heavy alcohol consumption, there was little reason for gay people to feel accepted.  That started to change, Cole said, when he hired a tough lesbian bartender who didn’t tolerate guff from anyone. 

" In the end, the club’s location may have enabled it more freedom in an already relatively permissive City," the historians suggest, because there were few families in the area and businesses in the vicinity didn't object to a successful entertainment venue.

According to the nomination’s historical account, “Unlike many gay bars which had a more ‘niche’ clientele, Darcelle XV Showplace was an entertainment venue, creating a place in which a wide variety of people felt comfortable together that was not exclusively a gay bar.  Many publications and other media, including mainstream radio and TV, have touted the club as ‘one of Portland’s must see establishments,’ but perhaps more importantly Darcelle XV Showplace has made a deep impact on many patrons over the years.


“Walter Cole/Darcelle is truly a cultural ambassador, offering not only an opportunity for an evening’s lighthearted fun, but underpinning that entertainment value to become known as a tireless supporter, ‘therapist,’ drag promoter, and philanthropist for the LGBTQ community in Oregon and the west coast.  Darcelle XV illustrates an era when drag helped the gay community make gay discrimination bearable. 

"Darcelle XV Showplace helped convince people that homosexuality was not to be feared or shunned. No similar venue on the west coast or even in the United States has been able to pull in both a ‘straight’ and gay clientele to a gay-owned club so successfully for so long.”

 Cole’s club is believed to the longest-running drag venue in the United States, and Cole is recognized as the nation’s oldest drag queen who still performs.

 The club has been closed during the pandemic.  Don Horn, executive director of Triangle Productions who helped prepare the National Register nomination with Kristen Minor, said the club hopes to reopen “whenever we can, to keep it going as long as possible.”

 Cole chimed in, “Forever.”

 If a state advisory committee approves of the nomination, it will be forwarded to the National Park Service for possible inclusion on the National Register.

 

 Special update:

Last week's report on the draft South Park Blocks Master Plan drew far more reader interest than any other post so far in this blog.  It shows the affection people hold for the park.

The city will accept comments on the plan only until June 29.  Please review the plan at this site, and then scroll down to the box that says "Take the Survey."  Please enter your comments after checking the various boxes.   This planning process deserves public attention.

https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/2aa14af546b543d99225798af7c367ae


Historic elements that are in jeopardy to some degree in the draft plan: 

1. Open Space adaptable to a variety of uses for the enjoyment of all.

2. Well-defined Boundaries

3. Deciduous Trees in Ordered Ranks

4. Simple Means

5. Arched-canopies encouraging long vistas

Wednesday, June 10, 2020

South Park Blocks Draft Plan




A draft master plan compiled by the Portland Parks Bureau proposes significant changes that would alter the appearance and use of  the city’s historic South Park Blocks.  After several months of under-the-radar planning by consultants and a citizen advisory committee, the public finally gets a chance to weigh in – but only online at this time.

Citizen comments offered by June 29 conceivably could affect the final plan.  A current schedule calls for a final version to be presented to the City Council for possible approval in August or September.

Details of the draft are available at the following link, which includes a link to a Surveymonkey questionnaire afterward:

https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/2aa14af546b543d99225798af7c367ae

Planners working on the project are fond of saying the draft maintains historic characteristics of the much-loved 12-block park, but they do not describe what they believe to be historic elements in any detail.  The result of the draft plan suggests a much more cluttered landscape and potential conflicts with bicyclists. 

As it stands, the draft plan would seriously impair what some park lovers believe to be the park’s historic fabric.  These proposed changes include removing of several dozen deciduous trees, adding a removable tensile canopy over much of one block on the Portland State University campus, and planting conifers  at the park’s southern border.

More puzzling yet would be slicing off 5 percent of the parks square footage along several blocks to create bike lanes for the Green Loop bicycle route, despite the city’s well-known difficulty of blending bikes in a pedestrian space at Waterfront Park.

The “good” news is that the plan calls for keeping the park’s historic canopy of deciduous trees that have shaded the park in summer and allowed natural light in the winter. However, the plan calls for removing the center row of the five straight rows that have existed at the park since it was first planted in 1877.

Laurie Matthews, a horticulturalist working for the MIG consulting firm, said removing the center row  would allow more room for the remaining trees to reach maturity.   “We really heard strong support for maintaining the tree canopy,” she said.

Matthews also recommended blending more species into the mix with the numerous American elms, but she did not specify what those could be.    “American elms are very special.  Not many species have that special characteristic.”  She said 6 to 10 other kinds of trees might be suggested later. 

An inventory made by committee of the Downtown Neighborhood Association that wants to save the park’s historic qualities concluded that the new landscape plan would take out 68 existing trees. That amounts to just over 20 percent of the existing stock. 

The tensile canopy held up by poles at PSU essentially would be more permanent than a tent but less permanent than a building.  “Permanent structures are definitely something we were told to stay away from,” said Rachel Edmonds, an MIG project manager.  The canopy would provide protection for the farmers’ markets during rainy seasons, but such a “roof” has no precedence in the park’s history.

Although the draft plan maps are not easy to interpret, it appears that 5 feet would be removed from the west side of the blocks from Montgomery to Salmon Street to provide room for bike lanes that also would extend slightly into the current 9th Avenue right-of-way.  The five feet at the western edges of those blocks currently are paved with hexagonal pavers for pedestrians.  Matthews said those walkways “are not very useable” and that most pedestrians prefer to use the center-block routes.

Nevertheless, no portions of the park’s 100 by 200 foot blocks have ever been dedicated to vehicular access.

The draft plan also suggests closure of Madison Street within the park, creating space for a “flexible programmable plaza” in the former street right-of-way.  The tentative plan also suggests “an overhead sculpture as a place-making feature” for the plaza that would attract attention and signify the plaza as a gathering space, close to entrances of the Portland Art Museum and Oregon Historical Society.

“I think that can actually bring people to our front door,” said Andrew VanDerZanden, an OHS employee who sits on the advisory committee.  Historically, the grassy, tree-covered park provided quiet spaces for pedestrians and flexible open spaces for occasional public events.  It was never intended to be a revenue-generating asset.

If people value the park for the green open spaces it provides, this is a good time to make that appreciation known.


Friday, June 5, 2020

New Fliedner Building


Chances are you’ve never heard of the New Fliedner Building in downtown Portland, let alone the “old” Fliedner that preceded it.

Yet if you go to SW 10th and Washington and look carefully at the multi-colored five-story building with the unmistakable Zig Zag Moderne detailing, you’ll probably never forget it. Zig Zag Moderne is a category of Art Deco architecture that needs no further definition once you notice all the crosshatches among the purely geometric ramblings.

Kevin Bond, a planner for Portland's Bureau of Planning and Sustainability, said Zig Zag Moderne is decoration applied to a traditional building, as opposed to Streamline Moderne in which the building itself is "streamlined" with rounded corners as if it were shaped in a wind tunnel.  Bond's comments were part of a presentation to the Portland Historic Landmarks Commission seeking support for the building's nomination to the National Register of Historic Places. 

The exterior we see today is a product of the fruitful mind of Richard Sundeleaf, an architect who practiced in Portland from the 1920s to the 1980s, decades when architectural fashions emerged from classical European roots to sleek, glassy modernism.  Sundeleaf’s work spanned both camps.  His best-known works today are probably the Jantzen Knitting Mills building in Northeast Portland and the Children’s Museum housed in what formerly was OMSI near the Oregon Zoo.  Old-timers will remember another Sundeleaf project, the long-gone Jantzen Amusement Park.

An interesting aspect of the “New” Fliedner is that the five-story building originally dates to 1906, and was the home for many years of the Eastern Outfitting Co., a successful clothing and department store for some 60 years.  Its proprietor, Joseph Shemanski, expressed his thanks for his success in Portland by donating the Shemanski Fountain in the South Park Blocks near Salmon Street.

In its original version, the Fliedner was a typical masonry building of the era with a heavy brick exterior.  When Eastern Outfitting outgrew its retail space at the end of the Roaring Twenties, Sundeleaf was hired to revamp the southern and western facades that face Washington and 10th Avenue.  The remodel was completed in 1931. 

What we see today, then,  looks nothing like the original building.  The “New” Fliedner is decked out with flatter but heavily colored and detailed facades with Zig Zag patterns.  There are decorative bands above the first floor and at the cornice; the second floor includes creative posts and lintels surrounding the windows; and the main entry on Washington would fit an Art Deco movie palace. 

Robert Mawson, an architectural history consultant who worked on the National Register application, called “the fabulous exteriors…great work by Sundeleaf.”  He said it is the only building downtown showing  Zig Zag Moderne styling. 

The ground floor of the building always has been used for retailing and the upper floors were used for offices.  The upper floors have been substantially gutted and have been vacant for many years.  Mawson said the new owner, a firm from Bellingham, Wash., intends to restore the upper floors for office use and return the ground floor to retail.

Matthew Roman, a member of the Portland Historical Landmarks Commission that reviewed the National Register application, said Sundeleaf is better known for having designed houses and industrial buildings rather than commercial buildings.  “I’m excited to see this building preserved.  It is a rare and unique instance downtown.”


The landmarks commission will forward the National Register application to a state advisory committee.  If that committee approves, the application will be sent to the National Park Service for final consideration.

In fact, Sundeleaf later performed another architectural magic trick in downtown Portland, just across Washington Street from the New Fliedner.  He added several floors to an older building and turned it into a 1950s glass skyscraper.  That is a story for another day.



Saturday, May 30, 2020

New Chinatown-Japantown Historic District: Who Cares?



Short answer to the question above: Not enough  people to make the Portland City Council change its mind about a 200 foot height ceiling it tried to impose in 2018. 


After getting its wrist slapped by the Land Use Board of Appeals and the Oregon Court of Appeals last year (see May 6 article below for the background) the council held a hearing on May 28 aimed at resolving the matter.  Although a final council vote will not happen until July, developers, architects, a lawyer and even some members of the Asian communities expressed support for the 200 foot height.

Before the council adopted the 200-foot maximum in 2018, the city Planning and Sustainability Commission had urged a 125 foot limit.   The Court of Appeals agreed that the council had not provided justification for the taller height limit “preserving and complimenting historic resources” as required by the city’s masterplan. 

Joe Zehnder, chief planner, contended that city policies on the pedestrian realm, building uses, infill and architectural detailing provided the necessary justification.

Although the City Council is not expected to change the 200 foot height when it takes a final vote, this fight is far from over.  Mayor Ted Wheeler said the Portland Historical Landmarks Commission would continue to rule on height and massing in an attempt to make new buildings fit the context of the rather tiny, ten square-block district.

“The Landmarks Commission will continue to do our job,” declared Kristen Minor, the commission’s chair, who objected to the 200 foot limit. But she added that when the council acknowledges the possibility of excessive heights and bulk, “You send a message that our work is just an obstacle to be overcome.” 

Rulings by the commission can be appealed to the City Council, but appeals have been rare historically.  Developers don’t like losing the additional time and money to undertake appeals.  When the difference might be between a five story building and 18 stories, that expense becomes less relevant. Minor's dedication to the Landmarks Commission's role suggests the strong possibility of new conflicts between the commission and the City Council when the economy revives. 

When it was approved in the late 1980s, the district spanning Third to Fifth Avenues between Burnside and Glisan Street contained buildings mostly one to four stories, Minor said.  The tallest was seven.  Since then, new buildings of eight and 16 stories have been added. Minor said 15 story  heights are not compatible with the district's historic context. Lynn Fuchigami Parks, executive director of the Japanese American Museum of Oregon, said many Japanese recall seeing their businesses and possessions wiped out quickly by internment during World War II.  She said Japanese now envision “erasure” of the neighborhood where they once had established a foothold.  “This neighborhood means everything to the Chinese community as well,” she said.

Raymond Cheng, a director of the Lan Su Chinese Garden that lies just outside the historic district, said  garden officials originally feared that 200-foot buildings would cast shadows impairing plants and fish at the garden.  He said the board changed its position when it learned that shadow studies required by the city would prevent those problems.

Helen Ying, chair of the nearby Old Town Community Association, also supported the greater heights, as did James Wong, who described himself as a property owner and developer.

Peggy Moretti, executive of Restore Oregon, a statewide architectural preservation advocate, described the district as a “fragile historic place that could be swallowed up by out-of-scale buildings.”  She urged the city to find ways to help owners brace their buildings against earthquakes and to require owners to make improvements so buildings do not deteriorate from “benign neglect” to become eligible for demolition.  The prospect of taller buildings could be a disincentive for maintaining older buildings on valuable sites. 

The council will hold a work session on July 2 to discuss any possible changes.  The odds of the council accepting any lower heights likely are about the same as modern science proving the pandemic to be a hoax.

SOME FUN STUFF

While the pandemic endures, the Architectural Heritage Center is adding some interesting videos about Portland's architectural history.  So far, Val Ballestrem, the AHC's education manger, has narrated these productions:

A.E. Doyle, one of Portland's most productive architects in the first half of the 20th Century


A history of Pioneer Courthouse Square and the buildings that preceded it on that block


These videos run six and seven minutes each. If our architectural history interest you, these will be enjoyable "views."












Monday, May 25, 2020

Hotel Chamberlain




The biggest and perhaps most complex restoration project in Portland for quite some time faced many challenges in meeting current building codes, replacing utilities, bolstering structural elements and reconfiguring rooms for modern needs.  Adding delays for a fast-breaking viral pandemic has made the task even tougher for the architecturally-interesting building at 509 S.E. Grand Ave.  

Problems notwithstanding, work on what is best known today as the former Schleifer Furniture store ranks as a major preservation victory and enhancement in the East Portland Grand Avenue National Historic District.  The building started life in 1907 as the Gayosa Hotel, coupled, ironically, with an earlier furniture retailer, Morgan-Atchley.  By 1917, the hotel was renamed Chamberlain, and housed residents in many of its 107 rooms until 1974.

The Schleifer firm managed the building from 1936 to 2016, and used some of the rooms after 1974 for  storage.  After Schleifer left, the new owners allowed the building to be used as a winter shelter for the homeless while planning proceeded for the renovation. 

Investors including Brad Malsin of Beam Development bought the building in 2015, and went to work on plans to remake the building.  As now envisioned, the Hotel Chamberlain will have 57 rooms above a restaurant and bar on the ground floor.  Malsin is an experienced redeveloper of old buildings on the East Side, including the Eastside Exchange,  Eastbank Commerce Center and the Olympic Mills Commerce Center.

After a prolonged period of planning and obtaining building permits, work was well underway in 2020, only to be shut down by the pandemic.  Though work undoubtedly will resume, what ultimately happens with the virus may affect the building’s future as a hotel.  There is no way to tell when the pandemic's scourge will release its grip on the hospitality industry. 

The Architectural Heritage Center defines the building’s style as French Second Empire.  In the late 18th century, that meant pieces of many earlier architectural styles jumbled together in exuberant fashion.  The Paris Opera House is perhaps the most notable example.  But what was exuberant to some, meant tastelessness  to others.  The French writer Emile Zola called Second Empire architecture “an opulent bastard child of all the styles.”

The Schleifer/Chamberlain building is a tame but charming example, one of few in Portland. The original architect is not known; the remodeling is being designed by Works Progress Architecture, a firm that has worked with Beam on other projects.  Notice the heavy lintels over the windows with exaggerated keystones, decorative frieze at cornice, and double columns of protruding bricks (called quoins) that add definition to the corners. As a contributing building in the historic district, the facades facing Stark and Grand cannot be substantially altered.  Ideally, the notable details 
Stark Street entrance 
should be highlighted by differing colors in the final paint scheme.

The foremost identifier of many Second Empire buildings, and present here, is the mansard roof with gables at the top.  The mansard roof became popular with developers in Paris, the story goes, because the city’s height limits were measured up to a building’s cornice, and did not include the roof.  Thus the mansard became a sneaky tool for adding an extra floor.

Historically, the original furniture dealer operated from a storefront facing on Grand Avenue.  It is easy to see today that a more elegant entrance was on the Stark side, with a bracketed chevron and a tall  three-panel window over the doorway.  This, no doubt, was the original entrance to the Gayosa, as it was first known.

The current plan, however, puts the hotel entry on Grand, no doubt for better visibility plus better access by automobile, bus and streetcar. 

When the renovation is finished, it will be an will make the block between Stark and Washington one of the most interesting in Portland.  The Chamberlain sits shoulder-to-shoulder with the masculine Logus Block of 1892, one of Portland’s best Richardsonian-Romanesque architectural examples.  Just across Grand Avenue is the Barber Block of 1889, which contains a veritable trove of popular Victorian era architectural details that make it a standout in the neighborhood -- or anywhere in Portland.  

Within a single block, people who take time to look at buildings will find much to delight their eyes .It will be a timeless – for now -- glimpse into the art of architecture at the turn of the 20th Century that cannot be replaced. 

Monday, May 18, 2020

Battle of the Park Blocks II*



It is quite amazing to think that 8.67 acres of the most iconic, historic and beloved land in downtown Portland has never been graced with a permanent building.  Yet it is the front yard for four churches, three major cultural institutions and one of the state’s biggest universities.

And a playground for toddlers, senior citizens and buyers of fresh vegetables.

The South Park Blocks comprise this historic turf, running 12 blocks from S.W. Salmon to Jackson Streets along S.W. Park Avenue.  When it was given to the city in 1852 – only one year after Portland’s incorporation – it seemed far from town.  The city's first dedicated park land lay fallow for 25 years before the first formal planting scheme was developed.  

Now, 168 years after pioneers in a small village magnanimously gave this land to the city, the question is how much “turf” will remain – and how much will be devoted to presumably more “active” public uses.  The Portland Bureau of Parks is working on a new masterplan for the park in a process that has received far too little public attention. 

First, let's glance at some history.  Rows of elms and poplars were planted in 1877 by Louis Gustav Pfunder, a pioneering horticulturist who earlier had worked on plantings for Central Park in New York and Golden Gate Park in San Francisco.  Since then, the blocks have been most notable for deciduous trees and green grass.  

By the late 19th century mansions by some of the city’s important business and political figures abutted the park, followed in the early 20th century by several seemingly high-rise apartments that still exist in what became densely populated neighborhood. 

A detailed inventory prepared for the Parks Bureau outlines many changes in the park since its first days.  At differing times, statues were added, walkways changed, lighting and some flower beds added.  In the early 1970s, the southern area of the park became a formal part of the Portland State University campus, bringing the addition of a performance deck and rows of seats. 

Two citizen groups are busy studying the South Park Blocks today from differing perspectives.  The Portland Parks Bureau, funded by a grant from a major downtown developer, is working with a Citizens Advisory Committee on a new “master plan” for the park.  Details are not yet final, but the proposal is expected to suggest new gathering spaces, more flower beds, conifers instead of elm trees and new plans for human seating.


Meanwhile, a committee of the Downtown Neighborhood Association is preparing an application to place the park on the National Register of Historic Places.  Acceptance on the register would not mean that no changes could occur, but would protect the “historic” characteristics of the park.

Regardless of all changes made over the years, the overriding purpose of the park has been to provide quiet green space, a living retreat from the pressure of high-density urban living.  Breaking up that ambiance with “visual clutter” would destroy the park’s historic essence and significance, says Story Swett, an architect with an extensive history of working on preservation projects.  He chairs the neighborhood committee working on the National Register nomination.

 “Despite all the pressures of the surrounding density, the overall character of the park continues to have its historic integrity,” Swett says.  “By breaking it up into small bite-sized pieces, the overall sense of a place for quiet contemplation and unstructured rest is ultimately lost.”

Seeking status on the National Historic Register is not a new idea.  Work on applications was begun in 1995 and again in 2000, apparently under the auspices of the city government.  However, the processes were never completed.  Final approval of the registration would require assent from the city’s Historic Landmarks Commission, the Oregon State Historic Preservation Office and the National Park Service.  City Council approval is not required for submitting an application. 

Meetings of the Park Bureau’s advisory committee have indicated little interest in historic elements of the park.  Trees are one of the contentious issues.  The Downtown Neighborhood Association likes the historic choice of elms because they provide shade in the summer and allow needed natural light in the winter after the leaves fall.  Proponents of conifers see evergreens as being a more indigenous choice, but the conifers by their circumferences would reduce open green space. 

You can view three preliminary design concepts from the Parks Bureau here:


The first, called Emerald Arrow, comes closest to retaining the historic sense of the park.  The other two, called Braided Districts and Mirrored Chain, add more intrusive elements.  When a final plan is proposed, this blog will provide an update with links to the plan and how to comment. 

The Parks Bureau, working with design consultants and the advisory committee, is expected to suggest a proposed master plan sometime in June.  The plan will have to be approved by the City Council at some point, since any final plan would require money for implementation.  Given the strong feelings shown by both citizen groups so far, the council hearing likely will not be a place for quiet contemplation.






*In 1970, Portland police in riot gear attacked protesters against the Vietnam War who had gathered near Portland State.  It quickly became known as the "battle of the Park Blocks." 


Wednesday, May 13, 2020

A Small Miracle


This story is so good, it deserves being told again and again.

Never in Portland, I believe, has so much research, time, energy and thoughtful care been invested in restoring the façade of a historic building that is only 25 feet wide. 

It is historic because the Hallock & McMillan building at 237 SW Naito Parkway, is the oldest building surviving downtown.  Built in 1857, it was one of the first to use brick construction and cast-iron elements on its eastern façade.  Absalom Hallock was the city’s first professional architect.  “The classical details of the columns and their applied ornaments provide the first public artwork appearing on Portland’s streets,” says architectural historian and local cast iron expert, William J. Hawkins III.

Earlier Hallock "remodel" 
Over the next 35 years, Portland developed one of the largest inventories of cast-iron buildings in the nation, though many of them subsequently were demolished.  Many grew larger and more ornate in decoration.  The neighboring Fechheimer & White building from from 1885 is an elegant example.

Fechheimer & White 
The historic façade of Hallock & McMillan was scraped off in the late 1940s to be replaced with something more “modern” and vapid.  Owner John W. Russell, who also owns two other historic buildings on the block, committed himself to restoring the original appearance.  Overall, the project took eight years to achieve completion last fall. 

The video here explains the process.  I  believe you will enjoy a few minutes looking at it.


Besides Russell, you will notice several key players in contemporary preservation work in the video.    They are Hawkins, architectural historian; Brian Emerick, an architect involved in many restoration/preservation projects; Bremik Construction Inc., a firm involved in many tasteful vintage building renovations; and Dave Talbot, who doesn't have speaking part in the video, is an expert at reproducing architectural details. If we care about our city and its history, we must appreciate the efforts to restore and preserve these early pieces of downtown. 
 .

The video does not detail another vital phase of renovation.  Engineers found ways to brace together three historic buildings on the same block (including the Dielschneider building facing on Oak Street)  to achieve greater strength against earthquakes.  Pioneer that he was, Absalom Hallock never had to worry about earthquakes.  

There is another interesting historical detail about the neighboring Hallock and Fechheimer buildings.  When pioneers platted the first streets of downtown Portland, they established lots with 25-foot frontages.  Their goal assumed the small size would be helpful in marketing.   Given blocks of 200 feet by 200 feet, that meant 16, 25 by 100 foot lots in each bock.  There are few 25-foot lots left today  because over the decades owners succeeded in aggregating neighboring lots so larger buildings could be erected.   If you go to see these two buildings to admire their cast iron architecture, take a moment to appreciate the scale of Portland's earliest development. 


Wednesday, May 6, 2020

Historic District Height Limits


There are no pretty pictures to display in this posting.  Instead, we look at a Portland planning policy about new building heights that poses serious risks to the city’s historic districts.

Some background:  City planners, developers the Planning & Sustainability Commission and the City Council have negotiated and argued for at least a decade about setting appropriate height limits for new buildings in the Chinatown-Japantown Historic district in inner Northwest Portland. 

Decades ago, height limits were set as high as 450 feet in a district where most historic structures are two and three stories.  After detailed hearings and study sessions, the Planning Commission later suggested 125 feet, enough for a 10 story building.  In 2018, the City Council finally adopted limits of 200 feet, which could amount to 17 or 18 stories.

Restore Oregon and other preservation organizations appealed over the 200 foot limit, contending that the City Council failed to comply with a  Portland Comprehensive Plan requirement of justifying development “while preserving and complementing historic resources.”  The Oregon Court of Appeals ruled that the city had failed to meet that standard.

The legal fix is easy enough, right?  Come back and ask the City Council to come up with some kind of verbiage about “preserving and complementing historic resources.”   In nice bureaucratic happy-talk, the hearing notice says the city’s action “will guide growth and development to make Portland’s urban core more vibrant, innovative sustainable and resilient, through new policies, regulations, investments and other actions.”  No mention of historic significance, of course. 

 The council plans to hold an electronic public hearing on May 28.  Citizens may submit written testimony in advance.  (See details at the end.)

The planning staff has offered a bundle of assorted reports dating back a couple decades from which it presumably will craft some sort of justification.  The chances of the council changing its mind and lowering the limits likely are nil.  In the view of Peggy Moretti, executive director of Restore Oregon,  125 feet would be an acceptable maximum, but not in all locations depending on the neighborhood context.

At the May 28 hearing, “I still think it’s important for people to raise their voices,” even if the cause is futile, Moretti says.  “At the same time, we need to find ways to mitigate the impact of this.”

How to do that?  “It needs to be made clear in all historic districts that the maximum is not an entitlement,” she says.  “The city must clarify that zoned heights in historic districts are a maximum, not a guarantee.  Without this clarification, developers believe they have an absolute right to the zoned height, and the Landmark Commission’s ability to ensure that new construction in historic districts is compatible with its context is gutted.” 

Under this scheme, the Portland Landmarks Commission would rule on whether a proposed building preserves and complements historic resources.  A developer dissatisfied with a commission ruling could appeal to the City Council.  Historically, appeals from landmarks commission decisions have been rare.

Moretti sees another downside if the 200-foot heights are allowed by right:  Intentional deterioration by neglect.  Owners might envision greater revenue by letting old buildings decay so they become more eligible for removal and replacement by larger structures.  “We really need to go after that,” she said.  “Heights inspire demolition by neglect.”

To submit written testimony in advance of the hearing, you can use the U.S. Mail and send to City Council, CC035 Plan, Re-Adoption Testimony, 1221 SW Fourth Ave., Room 130, Portland, OR 97204.

To submit electronically, go to portlandmaps.com/bps/mapapp and click on Central City 2035 and click the “testify” button.

To testify in person at the May 28 hearing at 2 p.m. register at Portland.gov/bps/cc2035.  Deadline for signing up is May 26.

If you are interested in the Oregon Court of Appeals decision (and finding out why you are glad you don’t practice law), click here: