Pages

Friday, April 25, 2025

Celebrating 75 years at the landmark Zion Lutheran Church

 

Regardless of religious views, Portland architecture enthusiasts will be able to enjoy the inside and the acoustics of a landmark church during a celebration of its 75th anniversary on May 3.

Zion Lutheran Church, at 1015 SW 18th Ave., is the first Mid-Century Modern church in Portland – and probably anywhere in Oregon – designed by the city’s most famous architect, Pietro Belluschi.  Its opening in May, 1950, drew 7,000 visitors on its first day, many attracted by newspaper construction photographs of its unusual design.

Festivities of the anniversary will include an organ recital by Zion’s organist, Floy Berentsen, and remarks by Belluschi’s son, Anthony, a retired architect who admires and celebrates his father’s work.  To Zion’s credit, the church has been well-respected and maintained over the decades by the congregation.  Like many other Belluschi works, Zion Lutheran is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

“With his expertise, talent and Italian charm, Pietro was able to convince congregations to embrace the elegant simplicity of Mid-Century Modern design while still integrating the familiar symbols of their traditions and beliefs” Anthony wrote in a history provided by the church.  Interestingly, the church turned down Belluschi’s original idea for a flat roof, but Belluschi soon accomplished that end by putting a flat roof on the Central Lutheran Church in Northeast Portland.


Bronze doors with angels ascending

The most graceful of Belluschi’s traditional symbols at Zion Lutheran are the elegant gothic arches that frame the sanctuary.  They are composed of glue laminated beams, a rather new technology of the post-war era. 

The late Ruth Hyde, a Zion historian and long-time church office manager, wrote in some detail about the church’s design.  “The use of space, light, color, scale, and simple materials in the nave and chancel has created a sanctuary which facilitates the worship of Zion congregation. The sanctuary has the power also to surprise and awaken a response in the unsuspecting visitor seeing it for the first time. For many it inspires a sense of awe.”

As designer of some 42 houses of worship in his lengthy career, Pietro Belluschi was well-aware of the importance of acoustics.  In 1984, 10 years before his death, he said, “An architect knows that the size and shape of a hall can determine the quality of sound received. The spoken word, the singing, and the music, particularly organ music, have different wave lengths and intensities and require different means of enhancing their quality, so portions of the church must absorb sound; others must reflect it; and speaking voices must be aided through electronic means.”

 The 75th anniversary celebration is bound to be a beautiful event – in many ways.

---Fred Leeson

 Join Building on History’s email list by writing “add me” to faroverpar463@gmail.com

 

 

Thursday, April 17, 2025

Trying to Save Architectural History at PSU

 

Blackstone Apartments

Lacking formal means of protesting the demolition of two historic buildings on the Portland State University campus, preservation activists are trying to appeal using old fashioned ways – writing letters and using personal connections to build support.

 PSU plans to demolish the Blackstone Apartments and the Martha Washington, two buildings that have been used many years for student housing, sometime after early July.  Both buildings have interesting historical pedigrees, but neither has been declared a city landmark.  Lacking such designation, there is no formal public hearing to oppose the demolitions.

 “We shouldn’t be tearing down housing in a housing crisis,” said Heather Flint-Chatto, executive director of the Architectural Heritage Center.  The environmental impacts of demolition and new construction also favor preserving the old buildings.

“This reckless move threatens PSU’s architectural heritage and the integrity of the Portland Park Blocks,” according to an AHC web page aimed at encouraging support for saving the two buildings.  SAVE HISTORIC PSU HOUSING — Architectural Heritage Center

 PSU has demolished a few other old residence halls in recent years, without adding any new units.  The university has an $80 million plan for new housing, but its development could be many years away.

 

Montgomery Hall/nee Martha Washington

Is there a better idea?

 “From both a sustainability and economic point of view, the Blackstone and Washington apartments could be redeveloped with the funding provided through a lend-lease approach,” says Henry Kunowski, an architectural historian and planning consultant.  Under that concept, PSU would grant a lease of up to 30 years to a developer or development team that would rehabilitate the buildings and collect the revenue.  At the end of the lease, the buildings would revert to PSU.

Both buildings suffer from deferred maintenance and internal repairs would be essential.

 The Blackstone, built in 1931 by prominent developer Harry Mittleman, faces directly on the South Park Blocks.  PSU earlier demolished the Parkway Manor that also faced the historic park, leaving a sad hole in the urban fabric.  The Blackstone was designed by Elmer Feig.  His use of Egyptian symbols on the façade reflects national interest in the discovery of the ancient tomb of King Tutankhamun.

The Martha Washington was built in 1916 by the Portland Women’s Union, a gathering of reasonably affluent “society” women in the early 20th Century who built the home for young women new to Portland who needed safe, stable housing.  It was designed by A.E. Doyle, Portland’s leading architect at the time.

 The Women’s Union later moved to another building and Doyle’s building, subsequently renamed Montgomery Hall, became student housing in 1970.   An interesting video history of the Women’s Union and its three housing locations is available here:

The Martha Washington Hotel & The Women Who Built Her

-----Fred Leeson

Join Building on History’s email list by writing “add me” to faroverpar463@gmail.com

 

 


Sunday, April 6, 2025

Whither Downtown Portland?

Ladd carriage house: Coming back anytime soon?

Like other urban centers, downtown Portland suffers today from vacant storefronts, vacant offices and boarded-up windows.  Starting in 2020, the COVID pandemic changed office practices and heavily crippled traditional downtown retail and nightlife.

Urbanists realize that major downtowns will not recover to being their former selves.  So, what are the options for improvement?  A Portland City Club panel with experts from San Francisco and Denver said cities’ priorities are largely similar: clean, safe streets; night-time and cultural activities; mixed uses with more housing; activated public spaces and pedestrian-friendly streets.

But they agreed every city has to find its own solutions; what works in one city might not in another.

Sarah Dennis-Phillips, director of economic and workforce development in San Francisco, offered a few interesting possibilities that Portland might consider.  She said a change in law allows bars to provide sidewalk drinking spaces which are proving popular.  She also said the city is working with landlords who are willing to offer up to six months of free ground-floor rent for new commercial businesses.

While concerts and cultural events can draw people downtown, Dennis-Phillips said cultural institutions themselves are facing financial challenges, presumably stemming from the Trump
Administration and many unrelated individual factors. 

“We have a good sense of what works and what people want,” she said.  But she said a key factor is figuring out how to maintain amenities without requiring on-going subsidies.

Like many cities, Portland’s downtown suffers from an office vacancy rate of approximately 30 percent.  Many of those offices will not be refilled, given the popularity of working from home learned during the pandemic.  Since 2022, Dennis-Phillips said, “The world has changed for good.”  While converting offices to housing is often suggested, she said realistic opportunities have proven rare.

Portland’s interesting supply of historic buildings potentially should assist in revitalizing downtown.  The most obvious candidate is the shuttered Ladd carriage house, which offers a turn-key opportunity for reopening an attractive fully-equipped bar and restaurant.

More problematic is the old Multnomah County Courthouse, once approved for being converted to office spaces and public events, and the magnificent Roman-style temple that once housed U.S. National Bank. Someday, one assumes that creative thinkers will find attractive uses for these engaging buildings that will help reenergize downtown Portland.

----Fred Leeson

Join Building on History’s email list by writing “add me” to faroverpar463@gmail.com